When I was a child growing up, the only kind of TV shows and stories that I was exposed to were all Western. Now that I reflect on it, almost all of the American shows that I watched really seemed to have no complicated plot, and it seemed as if the creators of the show just didn't really put too much effort into making their work good. As long as they could come up with something by the deadline, then it was fine with them. As a result, these shows never really had any deep emotional impacts on me during or after I watched them. It was basically like I watched an episode because I had nothing else to do, then moved on to something else without a second thought. That is not the kind of story that I am going to enjoy very much.
http://www.sodahead.com/fun/asian-cartoons-or-american-cartoons/question-1133367/?page=2 |
After I saw my first Japanese anime series in the year of 2011, I was amazed at just how different the experience was. The plot was so intricate that the author obviously put a load of work into it, and the characters were developed extremely well. I didn't even mind reading subtitles because it was just so much more interesting than what you could find on American television. You can actually become absorbed in the story in a much deeper way than with American shows. It made you really want to see the next episode in the series. Everything from the story down to the art, Japanese shows win hands down.
http://www.tumblr.com/tagged/western-animation |
Over the summer of 2012 I read and watched some of the best stories I have ever encountered in my life. I haven't turned on my TV again since.
Current Favorite Series:
Stein's;Gate
Episode 1: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tz-L_sgaLUY
(This series is hard to get into until around episode 4 or 5, but the plot and characters are excellent. Sword Art Online or Accel World are probably easier series to get into)
http://wall.alphacoders.com/big.php?i=345052 |
http://stuffpoint.com/sword-art-online/image/53472/sao-picture/ |
http://randomanimeviewer.wordpress.com/articles/spring-2012-top-10-anime/ |
I assume your comparing US cartoons to commercial fiction and Japanese anime to literary fiction. I didn't see an explicit mention of the reframing connection. My only question is if the shows you watched as a younger were aimed at the same age audience as they Japanese shows you like now?
ReplyDeleteCould there be an exposure bias affecting the US vs. Japan comparison? I'm assuming (and could well be wrong) that you watch subbed and dubbed anime. Wouldn't translators only go to the trouble of subbing and/or dubbing the better animes?
ReplyDeleteWell, I'm mainly comparing the popular anime series there and the popular shows here. (Spongebob, Dexter(not even a cartoon), etc) I'm not really thinking about some obscure American TV show like Mighty Orbots or something, I'm comparing the best with the best.
DeleteA big part of the appeal of anime that I didn't write about here is that they are mostly mature with serious themes, but they are also childish at the right times.
Also, I do watch some obscure series sometimes. (I have to say, there are some pretty bad series out there.)